PgMol Web -Web President says he was right at the heart of Everton’s penalty kick against Manchester United, but he says that the referee should have appeared another angle to withdraw Matigz de Legit on Ashley Young.
Three minutes after Everton’s 2-2 draw with Manchester United last month, Yong theatrical fell at the United Square under pressure from both De Legt and Harry Maguire.
The referee Andy Madle referred to the place – but Far Matt Donuhu sent him to the Pitchside monitor to review his decision.
Di Ligt had pulled the Young shirt trying to hold a loose ball, inciting the fall. Magir and then put his hand on the youth.
What the officials said:
Var: A possible penalty kick, presented in the field. Verify the decision to punish the field.
Restarting factor: I got a high degree if you prefer it.
Var: Show me the left hand Maguire.
Var assistant: The broadcast does not appear Maguire.
Var: No, I need a different angle to find out what the left hand Maguire does.
Avar: Is it Maguire or is it the other players, with the left hand?
Var: He described the left hand Maguire.
Avar: Another player beside Maguire.
Var: There is also de ligt. What are the behavior of De Ligt? minimum. Do you feel that the left hand of Maguire makes young people fall in this way? I do not see a procedure from the defender. I do not see a penalty there, and I will recommend a review of the field.
Avar: It is not a sustainable grip for me.
VAR then recommends going to the screen to look at the decision.
Var: The left arm of Maguire describes. I just want you to analyze if you feel that Ashley Young falls the way he does.
Reference: There is a connection. I felt that his arm was more than around him than in reality and I think Young was trying to make the most of the actual decision.
Var: Before leaving the screen, just think about the DE LIGT behavior as well. Again, I don’t think there is a mistake there, but I like to think about watching you.
Reference: I don’t see anything by De Ligt, so I am happy to restart the game with a drop ball.
Var: Ensure, restart with a drop -off ball.
Howard Web:
“The judgment was clearly punished in this position. It was believed that Maguire was withdrawn young people with his left hand and described it. The mouse knows this and the starting point of the examination will be.
“When VAR looks at it, Maguire does not do what the ruling sees it in the actual time. He sees a touch, but not attractive from Maguire. There is no less connection to the body. Young steps on the maguire stem and then spread in the leg and go to the ground.
“It is not a mistake by Maguire. Giving a penalty is clear and clearly is wrong in our opinion and VAR.
“You hear AVAR asking about De Ligt, and if he commits a crime or not. They are aware that he has done something.
“They ask the screen to consider the DE LIGT behavior, but I completely accept that the angles to judge at that stage do not show a clear vision of what De Ligt does.
“They need to show the corners earlier on the screen. I do not say that de Legit’s behavior is wrong, but they need to show another angle to make a decision on the screen.
“Some of these angles were shown on broadcasting and I think this is where some criticism came on how to play this process.
“We talked about how all contacts are not an unpleasant contact – just because you have a small tension that does not mean that it is something that is punished.
“We are trying to search for the effect of this procedure and the way Young falls forward, and he publishes his legs, in my opinion, is not associated with the amount of contact you see from De Ligt.
“We do not believe that this meets the threshold of a penalty in itself. This was the view of the referee on the screen and the angle was shown from behind the goal.
“I am sure that he would have reached the same decision anyway, but people could see that he saw full information.”
Wit
Watch: Web Ruling on AINA handball
Watch: Web Ruling on the Dorgu Red Card
Watch: Web judge on Zabarini
https://e0.365dm.com/25/02/1600×900/skysports-young-de-ligt-maguire_6836559.jpg?20250222145748